Posted on 2007.08.09 |
Comments (2) |
Music
This post has been imported from the old blog and has not yet been converted to the new syntax yet.
You're an audiophile, and you wish to listen to music in the highest possible quality, but on the other hand, you don't have that much disk space at your disposal to store everything as wave files. What are you to do?
Meet Free Lossless Audio Codec, or FLAC for the friends. A codec which allows you to store your music digitally without any loss of quality from the original source, but not as big as storing huge wave files. Unlike as with MP3 where data is discarded, resulting in an audible quality loss. MP3 is called a lossy format, while FLAC is lossless.
FLAC is a reasonably unknown player among the general public, but it's here to stay and become mainstream. There is a reasonable selection of hardware devices out there already who can playback FLAC files, while most respectable music players will play them on your PC, Winamp being one of them.
A small summary of the most important features of the FLAC format:
You can already buy FLAC music from smaller record companies, or find some free music recorded as FLAC files. Or you could simply store your own CD collection as FLAC files with this nice guide. Storing these files needs a bit more space than storing MP3 files however. To give you a small idea, these are the sizes and compression ratios (lower is better) after I archived my own CD collection:
I noticed that 'sung' music usually ends up with smaller files. I'm not sure why, but my guess is that there are more moments of silence when a person sings and grasps for breath, unlike electronic music where it's a constant stream. On the other hand, you'd expect electronic music to have recurring patterns and compress better. I'd have to withhold giving a good explanation for this, because I don't know either.
My personal approach towards FLAC is to have all the discs I have physically in the house, stored digitally on a central file server. After which I will stream the FLAC files itself to a high-end Hi-Fi setup, as if the disc itself would be playing on a normal CD player. But I will also be writing some automation tools to easily convert The Archive to other formats when needed, for example to play on my iPod.
If you're serious about music, I'd strongly recommend having a look at the FLAC format, the devices, software and possibilities, you won't regret it, even if you don't use it. Knowledge is power after all!
Are you using FLAC already? Leave some feedback on how you use it, and possible nice tools.
Meet Free Lossless Audio Codec, or FLAC for the friends. A codec which allows you to store your music digitally without any loss of quality from the original source, but not as big as storing huge wave files. Unlike as with MP3 where data is discarded, resulting in an audible quality loss. MP3 is called a lossy format, while FLAC is lossless.
FLAC is a reasonably unknown player among the general public, but it's here to stay and become mainstream. There is a reasonable selection of hardware devices out there already who can playback FLAC files, while most respectable music players will play them on your PC, Winamp being one of them.
A small summary of the most important features of the FLAC format:
- Lossless, no quality is lost when compressing the sound.
- Fast, the algorithm was designing to support very fast playback.
- Metadata, you can store all sorts of information in it to display when playing.
- Archiving, since a flac file is of the exact quality, you can convert it easily to lossy formats, like MP3.
- No DRM, there is no DRM on all flac files out there, for now.
You can already buy FLAC music from smaller record companies, or find some free music recorded as FLAC files. Or you could simply store your own CD collection as FLAC files with this nice guide. Storing these files needs a bit more space than storing MP3 files however. To give you a small idea, these are the sizes and compression ratios (lower is better) after I archived my own CD collection:
- Andrea Bocelli - Romanza : 351MB (Ratio: 55%)
- Arno - French Bazaar : 360MB (Ratio: 54%)
- Carl Orff - Carmina Burana : 229MB (Ratio: 40%)
- DJ Tiesto - Magik 5 - Heaven Beyond : 528MB (Ratio: 70%)
- Hed Kandi - Serve Chilled - HEDK068 : 458MB (Ratio: 60%) & 467MB (Ratio: 61%)
- Hed Kandi - Beach House - HEDK069 : 499MB (Ratio: 65%) & 553MB (Ratio: 70%)
- Praga Khan - Twenty First Century Skin : 399MB (Ratio: 65%)
- Praga Khan - Pragamatic : 466MB (Ratio: 70%)
I noticed that 'sung' music usually ends up with smaller files. I'm not sure why, but my guess is that there are more moments of silence when a person sings and grasps for breath, unlike electronic music where it's a constant stream. On the other hand, you'd expect electronic music to have recurring patterns and compress better. I'd have to withhold giving a good explanation for this, because I don't know either.
My personal approach towards FLAC is to have all the discs I have physically in the house, stored digitally on a central file server. After which I will stream the FLAC files itself to a high-end Hi-Fi setup, as if the disc itself would be playing on a normal CD player. But I will also be writing some automation tools to easily convert The Archive to other formats when needed, for example to play on my iPod.
If you're serious about music, I'd strongly recommend having a look at the FLAC format, the devices, software and possibilities, you won't regret it, even if you don't use it. Knowledge is power after all!
Are you using FLAC already? Leave some feedback on how you use it, and possible nice tools.
Well over a year old by now, but what the hey. Since Apple has their own proprietary lossless codec (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Lossless), I seriously doubt they will ever support FLAC. Especially given that you could convert FLAC to ALAC without any quality loss -- true for any two given lossless codecs. If you want your lossless music in an unencumbered format on your iPod, try rockbox (http://www.rockbox.org/) with support for FLAC and Vorbis among many others.
FLAC will never have any DRM. Ever. It's one of the goals of the projects.